Talk:Secret service

Untitled

In the USA, AFAIK, "secret service" always refers to the United States Secret Service. I think we may need some kind of disambiguation here.

I think this was far better the way it used to be. Haven't you ever heard of 007? Who does he work for? --Daniel C. Boyer 17:54 12 Jul 2003 (UTC)

he works for MI6. i personally believe it should redirect Cryo921 22:30, 7 September 2007 (UTC)

Lol, Daniel's question was rhetorical, but you're correct. 007 works for the Secret Service, which in this case, is MI6. - M0rphzone (talk) 21:47, 17 March 2012 (UTC)

USSS

The United States Secret Service is not a secret service.

According to the American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition, a secret service is: "1. Intelligence-gathering activities conducted secretly by a government agency. 2. A government agency engaged in intelligence-gathering activities."

According to United States Secret Service: The Secret Service has primary jurisdiction over the prevention of counterfeiting of currency and U.S. treasury bonds and notes, and protection of the President, Vice President, their immediate families, other high ranking government officials, past presidents and their spouses, certain candidates for the offices of President and Vice President, and visiting foreign heads of state and government (all called "protectees").

Secret and Service

Presumably, two of the criteria of a secret service are that such an organization should: (i) be a service (i.e. a body in government employ) and (ii) be "secret".

Question: what is it in terms of secrecy that defines a secret service ? Not wanting to be difficult, but genuinely seeking info on this, let's take the USSS as an example, as opposed to "secret services" in general. What is it about the USSS that is "secret" ? For example, is it that members are not allowed to have their faces photographed for the press, as in the British SAS ?

Confederate Secret Service

I'm hoping to work on a series of linked articles about secret operations during the US Civil War. During the Civil War the term secret service meant spies and saboteurs, not secret police. the Secret Service article really needs to be cleaned up. If the term relates to too many thigns, maybe this should just be a portal to "see also" secret police (domestic); spies and saboteurs, the USSS, etc.

Merger proposal

I propose that secret service be merged into secret police. I think that the content in this article is more or less identical to the secret police article (though, admittedly, both could stand to be improved), and the secret police article is of a reasonable size that the merging of will not cause any problems as far as article size or undue weight is concerned. -- 50.53.112.55 (talk) 08:20, 4 November 2015 (UTC)

Secret police and secret service are considered two different things where the secret police are the police force that works for the government. That's what makes it different from the secret service. --Rtkat3 (talk) 23:20, 30 November 2015 (UTC)

VASTLY different concepts, although primarily a product of actual usage rather than merely the words themselves. "Secret police" has a strong connotation of a powerful domestic Federal police force which operates outside the normal laws and in secrecy against political crimes, like the KGB or the Stasi. They would be more accurately known as "political police". In the US, the Secret Service are bodyguards for the government and anti-counterfeiters; by intentional design, they have zero authority to investigate or prosecute any other kind of crime and must defer to the FBI (the Federal police force). In England, "secret service" refers to the Secret Intelligence Service, aka MI6, which (like the American CIA) is only allowed to operate outside the country; again, by design, they are prevented from having any role as domestic police. 45.47.184.148 (talk) 20:08, 21 February 2016 (UTC)