User:Radicalsubversiv/Chuck F/172ver

This is what I put together a couple of weeks ago. I didn't finish going through everything as I misunderstood and thought both Reithy and Chuck had been banned from Wikipedia indefinitely. It only goes up to about November 15. You are welcome to mine it for any evidence you don't have already. If it has been proven or concluded that Chuck and Reithy are not the same person then the Reithy-only stuff should probably be removed.

6-11 September

Chuck F, using the ip 203.112.19.195, deletes a chunk of factual information from Libertarianism: [1]. He then reverts all changes that had been made of the over the previous two days: [2]. Those changes appear to have been good faith edits.
The next day, Chuck F continues to delete information from Libertarianism: [3]
Over the next three days there are a number of small revert wars on Libertarianism, several involving Chuck F. He shows awareness of the three-revert rule, which he and other users break, here and here.

10-11 October

Revert wars between Chuck F and several other users (Reithy, User:Chmod007, anon 24.92.130.139 [who may be Reithy] and User:Seth Ilys) over different edits on Michael Badnarik. This war follows edits by Chuck and Reithy (in his second edit with that username) and failed attempts to discuss these on the Talk page. Chuck refuses to allow certain edits to stand and removes others as a by-product of his reverts. The revert war between Chuck and 24.92.130.139 results in page protection. Edits: [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10]. On Talk: [11], [12], [13].
After Reithy edits Michael Badnarik, Chuck places an NPOV notice on Virginia Trioli: [14], an article created by Reithy on 8 October in his first edit with that username . Reithy objects to the wording on the talk page: [15]
Reithy edits United States Libertarian Party: [16]. Although it is broadly agreed that the article suffered from POV problems, it is also felt by other editors that his edits go too far towards the opposing POV. He is reverted by User:Radicalsubversiv. He reverts this revert and then makes more edits. He is reverted by User:Pstudier, and reverts this revert: [17], [18]. Rapid-fire reverts continue, Reithy's edits descending into vandalism: [19], [20], [21]. Reithy vandalises the user page of User:Pstudier: [22]. He is listed on Wikipedia:Vandalism in Progress : [23], [24]. User:1644 appears and begins editing United States Libertarian Party: [25]. These appear to be good-faith edits. This user stops shortly after midnight (and never edits Wikipedia again) and user:Radicalsubversiv and User:Nat Krause work on these edits, reverting where appropriate but accepting some of the additions: [26]

12 October

Chuck F, also posting from 203.112.19.195, reverts all of the recent changes on United States Libertarian Party, removing facutal and NPOV information and initiating a revert war in which he is conflict with User:Radicalsubversiv and User:Nat Krause: [27], [28]. Reithy returns to the article, restoring his edits despite other editors' objections: [29]. Reithy is now involved in a revert war against Chuck and User:Rhobite. The following are example edits: [30], [31], [32], [33], [34]. Chuck is indiscriminate in his reverts: [35]. The page is eventually protected: [36]. The edit wars do not recommence when it is unprotected on 23 October, even though the disputes have not been resolved on Talk: [37].

16 October - 2 November

Chuck F returns to reverting Libertarianism: [38]
User:Guido1970, a sockpuppet of Reithy, edits Michael Badnarik: [39]. Chuck reverts these edits and then makes further edits himself: [40], [41]. Chuck exchanges several reverts with User:Rhobite: [42]. There follows a revert war between Chuck and User:Lukewilson with User:MunchieRonnie (Reithy sockpuppets), until the page is again protected: [43], [44], [45]. Relevant Talk: [46]
Reithy (as Lukewilson) edits Libertarianism, Chuck reverts him: [47], [48]. There follows a series of edits and then an extensive revert war by Chuck against User:Chameleon (briefly, doesn’t break three-revert rule), Reithy and at least two different unregistered users (all of whom break three-revert rule many times over, as does Chuck), until article protected on 2 November (until 15 November): [49], [50], [51], [52], [53], [54], [55], [56], [57], [58], [59], [60], [61], [62], [63], [64], [65], [66], [67], [68], [69], [70], [71], [72], [73].
Reithy posts personal information about Chuck on 23 October: [74], [75]. This information leads to Reithy's subsequent edits on Temple University and Roppongi Hills.
Reithy edits Temple University. Chuck initiates a revert war, each reverting at least ten times in the space of eight hours, until another user intervenes: [76], [77].
Reithy edits Roppongi Hills. Chuck reverts. This is followed by a series of daily edits and reverts over several days, until the page is protected on 2 November, remaining protected until 15 November: [78], [79], [80], [81], [82], [83], [84], [85], [86], [87], [88].
On 30 October Chuck F removes NPOV tag from Michael Badnarik, even though there remain unresolved POV concerns on the Talk page: [89]. Chuck, Reithy and several users that appear to be Reithy's sockpuppets, along with other users, make a series of reversions until the page is again protected on 2 November, remaining protected until 4 November: [90], [91], [92], [93], [94], [95], [96], [97].
Chuck reverts something Reithy added to Temple University, and then engages in a revert war with User:Sekicho (who does not break three-revert rule), then Reithy (who does break the rule, as does Chuck), until the article is protected on 1 November by User:Michael Snow, remaining protected until 15 November: [98], [99], [100], [101].

5 November

Chuck F reverts an edit by Reithy on the recently unprotected Michael Badnarik, stating that encyclopedias are "meant to build people up": [102]
Reithy trolls Talk:Liberal Democratic Party of Australia: [103]

8-12 November

Reithy inserts a POV statement into Michael Badnarik, and is reverted by User:Rhobite and User:Chmod007: [104], [105]
Chuck makes a number of edits to Michael Badnarik, with a mis-leading edit summary: [106]. Brief revert war between Chuck and User:Chunkycustard, presumed Reithy sockpuppet: [107]. The article is subsequently vandalised by several potential sockpuppets of Reithy: User:Mirvern (immediately reverted by Chuck: [108]) , User:Sentientbeast and User:Sojourn (reverted by User:Rhobite and User:Improv in a timely fashion: [109], [110]).

11 November

Chuck, as 216.148.246.90 (see [111]) and possibly 67.81.104.32, vandalises 2004 U.S. Election controversies and irregularities: [112], [113], [114].

13 November

200.79.91.5, possibly Chuck F (see [115]), vandalises Wikipedia:New user log: [116]
- That is an open proxy and is probably not Chuck F: spammers use those even more than he does. —No-One Jones ^(m) 09:45, 6 Dec 2004 (UTC)

Still to look at

Avoiding bans, ignoring temporary injunctions

User:Chuck F has broken the Temporary Injunction against him, posting with the following IP addresses: